Late Stage Interview Success: What Nobody Tells You

You made it to final rounds — Congratulations, you're a badass! 🎉

Now what?

How do you make sure you don't squander this precious opportunity to FINALLY close out this job search?!

(First off, that's a stressful way to think about it. If you get one, you can get another)

5 members of my Accelerator are in final rounds right now so these questions have come up:

• “I have 6 back-to-back interviews and I’m wondering how to maintain my energy and stay sharp.”
• "I'm meeting with the hiring manager again. What else could they want to know about me?"
• "Looks like I'm scheduled with a bunch of different team members. How do I best prepare?"

Late stage interviews are intense for candidates.

In this newsletter, I'm peeling back the curtain & sharing tips to help you feel more at ease.

I used to be a Customer Success Manager at a recruiting tech startup called Dover. I worked directly with founders, VPs, and recruiters on over 100 teams. I witnessed interview loops across tech companies ranging in size and stage, across every role you can think of.

Here's what I learned:

There is not 1 universal playbook to late-stage success. But understanding these themes will help.

Early-stage companies:

They're often flying by the seat of their pants when it comes to hiring. The founder who attracted you with that fancy VP title might get cold feet about actually giving it away (yes, this happened to one of my clients).

Every "first of" hire is a net new interview loop that hasn't quite been proven out. If you're a guinea pig for a new process, they'll likely want to gather data from other candidates before moving forward. They may or may not have a recruiting partner to hold them accountable to making a timely decision.

Other companies are fast movers because they have a burning need for this role to get closed. They also typically have an extra high hiring bar for talent (founders always do). They need to equally sell YOU on why taking a bet on this tiny company with huge potential is worth betting your career on.

More established companies:

They typically have a more robust recruiting process, but not always. The largest public usually have structured interview guides — companies like Microsoft, Meta, Amazon, Google, Spotify, and Apple publish their interview guides to help you succeed. A quick search for “[Company Name] interview guide” can give you invaluable insights into exactly what they’re looking for. If you find one, use it.

Larger companies often have longer hiring processes as they have tons of candidates to choose from and typically, build their hiring plan a bit further ahead. They typically have pretty long and robust processes, especially for more senior roles. In the later stages, they're probably selling you more on the compensation package than the long-term equity package since you want that big name brand on your resume.

Regardless of company stage:

They’re not just evaluating your skills anymore — they’re assessing values alignment.

And YOU should be assessing if your values align with theirs too.

I’ve seen candidates get a verbal offer only to get rejected solely because they mentioned having work-life balance is important to them. It's a shame it took final rounds for this to come to light, but it was a major bullet dodged.

Making the wrong hire is expensive in time and money.

This is why companies are so particular about giving out offers. The cost of moving the wrong person forward is much higher than simply scheduling the next interview.

Let's help you maximize your chances 👇👇👇

What’s really happening in final rounds (and how to prepare strategically):

• The recruiter is your friend. Don’t be afraid to ask them “What makes candidates really stand out at this stage?” or “What’s the best way to prepare?” They want to close this role as much as you want to land it.
  ​
• For panel interviews, understand each interviewer’s role. Think about how your future position would intersect with their function. They’re imagining weekly meetings with you — show them what that collaboration could look like.
  ​
• Culture interviews often tie directly to company values. For example, if they list “Fail fast, fail forward” as a company value, prepare stories about times you’ve run experiments, what happened, and lessons learned. Keep these stories ~2-min and more focused on your thought process than your technical skillset. It's best to you have 5-8 PARADE stories ready to go. Map them back to company values!
  ​
• That final chat with the hiring manager: It’s often their gauge of whether you’d accept an offer. If you're in the final stages, the company should be trying to sell YOU too. Last thing they want to do is give an offer to someone who's heading to their competitor and miss out on their 2nd favorite candidate. Use this interview as a chance to build further rapport with your future manager. Don't be afraid to ask them your open questions and treat it like a collaboration.
  ​
• For 1-hour interviews, don’t stress about needing 20 different behavioral stories. They likely won’t ask back-to-back behavioral questions for that long. If it's not described as a technical interview, expect a mix of getting to know you, situational discussions, and deeper dives into specific scenarios. And always come with a list of questions specific to the interviewer.

Maintain your energy through marathon interview days:

• Treat it like athletic event prep. Hydrate well, eat your protein, all that jazz.
• Take mini-breaks between sessions to reset (even 2 minutes of deep breathing helps)
• Keep your blood flowing. Do some stretching, jumping jacks, or 2-min dance party between interviews
• Have water and good snacks ready for longer breaks — and coffee because duh.

Detach from the outcome:

You can do everything “right” and still not get the offer. This is part of the process.

I've interviewed candidates who were insanely qualified... but ultimately they were not a culture fit with our team. And therefore wouldn't be successful in the role. It stings, but it's much better for both sides in the long-term.

It's better to get rejected in the final rounds vs. wanting to quit or getting let go 1 month in because it wasn't a good match.

The key is detachment from the outcome (Learn how: The Art of Detachment in Your Job Search).

Control the controllables (your preparation, your energy, your mindset), and let go of the rest.

Rooting for you big time!!!

If you’re not consistently making it to late stage interviews, you’re blending into the crowd in this crowded job market.

Watch my free 90-minute training to stop getting those “We went with someone else” emails. Learn how to become THE top 1% candidate who stands OUT to get hired for the dream role you can’t wait to wake up for in 2025.

​GRAB THE FREE TRAINING. Only available until Monday Jan 20th.

Have a question you want me to answer in another newsletter? Hit reply.

Let’s win together,